* = Deceased
| Year | Inductee | Association | Category |
| 1982 | Joe Thum (*) | New York City | Meritorious - Charter Member |
| 1982 | Allie Brandt (*) | Lockport | Ability - Charter Member |
| 1982 | Frank Caruana (*) | Buffalo | Ability - Charter Member |
| 1982 | Grazio (Graz) Castellano (*) | New York City | Ability - Charter Member |
| 1982 | Joe (Chesty) Falcaro (*) | New York City | Ability - Charter Member |
| 1982 | John Koster (*) | East Nyack | Ability - Charter Member |
| 1982 | John O. Martino (*) | Syracuse | Ability - Charter Member |
| 1982 | James (Jimmy) Smith (*) | Buffalo | Ability - Charter Member |
| 1982 | Tony Sparando (*) | Rego Park | Ability - Charter Member |
| 1982 | Barry Spinella (*) | New York City | Ability - Charter Member |
| 1982 | Andy Varipapa (*) | West Hempstead | Ability - Charter Member |
| 1984 | Steve Czerwinski (*) | Buffalo | Outstanding Ability |
| 1984 | Maurice Hayes (*) | Rochester | Meritorious Service |
| 1984 | John Quinzi (*) | Rochester | Outstanding Ability |
| 1984 | Joseph Robelotto (*) | Albany | Meritorious Service |
| 1984 | Berard (Bert) Sarno, Sr. (*) | Syracuse | Meritorious Service |
| 1985 | William Marchese (*) | Buffalo | Meritorious Service |
| 1985 | George A. Obenauer (*) | Buffalo | Meritorious Service |
| 1985 | James Schroeder | Buffalo | Outstanding Ability |
| 1985 | Larry Sutton (*) | Rochester | Outstanding Ability |
| 1986 | Eddie Adams (*) | Buffalo | Outstanding Ability |
| 1986 | Joe Difiglia (*) | Buffalo | Outstanding Ability |
| 1986 | Greg Griffo | Syracuse | Outstanding Ability |
| 1986 | Addison Jones (*) | Kingston | Meritorious Service |
| 1986 | Al Lattin (*) | New York City | Meritorious Service |
| 1986 | Richard (Skip) Vigars, Sr. (*) | Albany | Outstanding Ability |
| 1986 | Jack Zack (*) | Buffalo | Outstanding Ability |
| 1987 | Robert Allen (*) | Westchester | Outstanding Ability |
| 1987 | Vic Herrmann | Buffalo | Outstanding Ability |
| 1987 | Blase P. (Ben) Palumbo (*) | Buffalo | Meritorious Service |
| 1987 | Edwin Wildey (*) | Rochester | Meritorious Service |
| 1988 | Robert Lynch (*) | Yonkers | Meritorious Service |
| 1988 | Chet Power (*) | Rochester | Meritorious Service |
| 1988 | Joe Minella (*) | Rochester | Meritorious Service |
| 1988 | Joe Schmidt | Albany | Outstanding Ability |
| 1988 | George Young (*) | Long Island | Outstanding Ability |
| 1989 | Herbert E. Burns (*) | Tonawanda | Meritorious Service |
| 1989 | John Walther, Jr. | Albany | Outstanding Ability |
| 1989 | Lil Villani | Niagara Falls | Outstanding Ability |
| 1989 | Ralph Engan (*) | Westchester | Outstanding Ability |
| 1990 | William Landgraf (*) | New York City | Meritorious Service |
| 1990 | Morris Cramer | Troy | Outstanding Ability |
| 1990 | Victor Giromini | Syracuse | Outstanding Ability |
| 1990 | Butch Hoefner (*) | Rochester | Outstanding Ability |
| 1991 | John R. Nevada | Rochester | Meritorious Service |
| 1991 | Harold Shaul (*) | Binghamton | Meritorious Service |
| 1991 | John Russo (*) | Syracuse | Outstanding Ability |
| 1992 | Louis Barnard | Elmira | Outstanding Ability |
| 1992 | Ben Berinstein (*) | Syracuse | Meritorious Service |
| 1992 | John R. Capozzi | Ithaca | Meritorious Service |
| 1992 | Joseph Koch (*) | Rochester | Outstanding Ability - Veteran |
| 1992 | Joseph Malambri (*) | Fulton | Meritorious Service |
| 1992 | Marty Piraino | Syracuse | Outstanding Ability |
| 1993 | Joseph Higgins | Fulton | Meritorious Service |
| 1993 | J. Nelson Thurston (*) | Lockport | Meritorious Service |
| 1993 | Joseph Paussa, Jr. | Syracuse | Meritorious Service |
| 1993 | Anthony Quaranto, Sr. | Niagara Falls | Meritorious Service |
| 1993 | Louis Scrimale | Syracuse | Outstanding Ability |
| 1994 | Jerry Cargill, Sr. | Endicott | Meritorious Service |
| 1994 | Ken Campbell (*) | Ithaca | Outstanding Ability |
| 1995 | Sam Furcinito (*) | Utica | Meritorious Service |
| 1995 | Charles Young (*) | Albany | Meritorious Service |
| 1995 | Frank Santore (*) | New York City | Outstanding Ability |
| 1995 | Jerry Back (*) | Buffalo | Outstanding Ability |
| 1995 | Edward Reddy | Syracuse | Meritorious Service |
| 1995 | Phil Cleary | Binghamton | Outstanding Ability |
| 1995 | Ray DiSanto | Rochester | Outstanding Ability - Veteran |
| 1996 | Stephen P. Donahue | Auburn | Meritorious Service |
| 1996 | Milton E. Alt (*) | Rochester | Meritorious Service |
| 1996 | Fred O. Reed (*) | Clyde | Meritorious Service |
| 1996 | Phil Versace | Poughkeepsie | Outstanding Ability |
| 1996 | Lou Campi (*) | New York City | Outstanding Ability |
| 1996 | Bruce Koch | Rochester | Outstanding Ability - Veteran |
| 1997 | Robert B. Lowe | Tonawanda | Meritorious Service |
| 1997 | Kenneth C. Kreger | Tonawanda | Meritorious Service |
| 1997 | Arthur Jeziorski | Buffalo | Outstanding Ability |
| 1997 | Mort Lindsay (*) | New York City | Outstanding Ability |
| 1998 | Anthony "Nin" Angelo | Lockport | Outstanding Ability |
| 1998 | Junie McMahon (*) | New York City | Outstanding Ability |
| 1999 | Angelo Bell | Batavia | Meritorious Service |
| 1999 | Joe Goleblewski | Buffalo | Outstanding Ability |
| 1999 | Vince Dinapoli, Sr. | Rochester | Outstanding Ability - Veteran |
| 1999 | Mark Chafel (*) | Rochester | Outstanding Ability |
| 2000 | William Schwartzenberg | Westchester | Meritorious Service |
| 2000 | Thomas DeChalus | Eastern Long Island | Meritorious Service |
| 2000 | Marty Casio (*) | New York City | Outstanding Ability |
| 2000 | Al (Lindy) Faragalli (*) | New York City | Outstanding Ability |
| 2000 | Jim Lewis | Albany | Outstanding Ability - Veteran |
| 2000 | Gus Lampo | Endicott/Oneonta | Outstanding Ability - Veteran |
| 2000 | Don Gates | Syracuse | Outstanding Ability |
| 2001 | Elmer Seidel | Rochester | Meritorious Service |
| 2001 | Ray Barton (*) | Elmira | Outstanding Ability |
| 2001 | Pete Cambio | Buffalo | Outstanding Ability - Veteran |
| 2001 | Richard (Skip) Vigars, Jr. | Schenectady | Outstanding Ability |
| 2001 | Hugo Mcgroty | Schenectady | Outstanding Ability |
| 2002 | Vito Galligano | Rome | Meritorious Service |
| 2002 | John Spadaro | Eastern Long Island | Meritorious Service |
| 2002 | Martin Fichera | Syracuse | Outstanding Ability |
| 2002 | Bud Schwabl | Buffalo | Outstanding Ability |
| 2003 | Fran Bax | Niagara Falls | Outstanding Ability |
| 2003 | Angelo Russo (*) | Buffalo | Outstanding Ability |
| 2004 | Mike Christie | Albany | Outstanding Ability |
| 2004 | Andy Melynk | Syracuse | Outstanding Ability |
| 2004 | Frank Hermans (*) | Syracuse | Outstanding Ability |
| 2004 | George Zaharis (*) | Johnson City | Outstanding Ability |
| 2005 | Frank Asselta | Utica | Outstanding Ability |
| 2005 | Mike Tryniski | Fulton | Outstanding Ability |
| 2006 | Leo Casarsa | Buffalo | Outstanding Ability |
| 2006 | Michael Daley | Syracuse | Outstanding Ability |
| 2006 | Sam Ventura | Syracuse | Outstanding Ability |